lunedì 17 aprile 2017

YEAR V - Overview of MODERN ENGLISH LITERATURE


MODERN ENGLISH LITERATURE: AN OVERVIEW

I am hereby borrowing a fellow teacher's words.
Many thanks to William Mallinson

We kick off with two superb dramatists and writers, Oscar Wilde
(1854-1900) and George Bernard Shaw
(1856-1950). Wilde was quintessentially Irish in wit, humour, verbal prowess, blood, and origin, yet, having studied at Trinity College Dublin and then Oxford, was very ‘English’ in a pleasantly louche, supercilious and upperclassish  way. In contrast, Shaw was an Anglo-Irish Protestant, morally, socially and politically conscious, even being a founder member of the Fabian Society. He was also self-taught, having left school at the age of fourteen. Their differences are reflected in their work, although their pithiness unites them. Wilde is perhaps best known for ‘Picture of Dorian Gray’. Grey leads a life of debauchery, while remaining handsome and in good shape. But his portrait becomes increasingly corrupt and horrid: it represents his soul. The ending is pretty horrific. There is of course more to the book than just that, and although it is a superb work, I wouldn’t recommend it to adolescents! In the preface Wilde writes; ‘There is no such thing as a moral or immoral book. Books are well written, or badly written.’ In other words, he seems to be saying that art is for art’s sake. Another of his well-known works is the play, ‘The Importance of being Earnest’, from which we have the gem: ‘Really, if the low orders don’t set us a good example, what on earth is the use of them?’ Shaw found the work hateful and sinister, exhibiting ’real degeneracy’. In this connexion, on the other hand, Wilde said of Shaw: ‘He hasn’t an enemy in the world, and none of his friends like him.’ Other witty Wilde sayings are: ‘Modern journalism justifies its own existence by the greatest Darwinian principle of the survival of the vulgarest.’; ‘A cynic: a man who knows the price of everything and the value of nothing.’; ‘I can resist anything except temptation.’;  and ‘When good Americans die, they go to Paris.’. Wilde’s wild life seems to have led to a tragically early demise, not as early as Mozart, but still premature: he sued the father of a poet friend of his, Lord Alfred Douglas, for libel, for accusing him of performing sodomy with his son (the poet). Wilde lost the case, was arrested, and sent to Reading Gaol for two years, for sodomy. He then left for Paris, changing his name to Sebastian Melmoth, dying two years later. Was he Dorian Gray? Was he a homosexual? Having read ‘De Profundis’ (which he wrote in prison) I can find no forensic evidence of his admitting to having actually practiced pillow-biting and shirt-lifting, but then perhaps he was a teaser. Well, perhaps he had certain tendencies towards young men, but the question is whether it was right to send him to gaol. I leave this to your judgment. It is not an easy question, since one needs to look at the morality of the Victorian Age, which some say had an element of hypocrisy: sometimes, those who persecute people manically and morally for something, are trying to hide their own tendencies, even from themselves…. At any event, having run out of cash, and written ‘The Ballad of Reading Gaol’, this former witty wordsmith par excellence said not long before he died: ‘I shall have to die beyond my means.’  He left a wife and two children, for whom he had written a lovely, but slightly frightening book of tales. How great would he be today, had he lived to Shaw’s age? He is great enough, as it is.

Shaw, perhaps somewhat more mature emotionally than Wilde, and surely a decent enough chap, was, like Wilde, healthily critical of people, but more as members of what we term ‘society’. Thus, in his plays, he criticized, inter alia, slum landlords and private doctors. In the preface to ‘The Doctor’s Dilemma’, he writes: ‘Thus everything is on the side of the doctor. When men die of disease, they are said to die from natural causes. When they recover (and they usually do), the doctor gets the credit of curing them.’ His play applies very much to today. Shaw was also an expert on class. If you wish to gain some insight into class and accent in England, you should red ‘Pygmalion’. If you wish to understand something about the England-Ireland problem, you can read ‘John Bull’s other Island.’ Some memorable sayings from Shaw are: ‘We have no right to consume happiness without producing it than to consume wealth without possessing it’; ‘He knows nothing; and he thinks he knows everything. That clearly points to a political career.’;  and ‘ He who can, does. He who cannot, teaches.’ I escape this definition, since I do not teach, but try to help students to learn. He comments on the English were cutting; for example: ‘A person who thinks he is moral when he is only uncomfortable.’

Our course then rushes through John Galsworthy


Joseph Conrad (not even British-born)


and  T.S. Eliot
This highly educated chap is known, inter alia, for ‘Old Possum’s Book of Practical Cats’. He wrote the play ‘Murder in the Cathedral’, a very good theatrical adaptation of the murder of Archbishop Thomas Becket. One of my favourite quotes of his, from ‘The Rock’, is: ‘Where is the wisdom lost to knowledge, where is the knowledge lost to information and where is the word we lost in words?’

After a brief glimpse of the amazing American Ezra Pound
who found Europe and Italy in particular, more to his liking intellectually than the USA, we come to William Yeats (1865-1939).
He is the quintessential Celtic Irishman, a friend of Shaw and Wilde, and a good dramatist and poet. ‘The Celtic Twilight’, a collection of traditional Irish stories, is a good pointer to Yeats’ thinking. Jumping now to Henry James (1843-1916),
an American who, unlike many, preferred to settle in London rather than Paris, we see a man who could pick up the apposite word with the point of his pen, in a meticulous fashion. I find his style too precise for my liking, the very antithesis of ‘stream of consciousness’ writing. Nevertheless, he was a competent writer. ‘The Turn of the Screw’ is a good ghost story.

Thomas Hardy (1840-1928)
a giant in English literature, is worth  chubby paragraph.
A poet who wrote novels, he was born to a modest family (his father was a stonemason), trained as an architect, but returned to his beloved Wessex to write. Beautifully written, his novels can be quite pessimistic: ‘Tess of the D’Urbervilles’ ends with the heroine’s execution for stabbing her husband to death, a husband whom she was emotionally pressurised into marrying, although she loved another. ‘Jude the Obscure’ ends with three children hanging dead behind a door, on clothes hooks. His stories often bring out what he saw as the injustice of the divorce laws, especially for women who had married the wrong man, and were then trapped in their marriage, and how they and their lovers were then ostracized by society. His writing was sensitive, and some of his descriptions of nature in his beloved Wessex are touching.

We now look at three childrens’ writers, Lewis Carroll
(real name Charles Lutwidge Dodgson, an Oxford mathematician, non-practising Anglican deacon, and photographer, 1832-1898),

Kenneth Grahame (1859-1932)
, and Beatrix Potter (1866-1943),
Few have not heard of Carroll’s ‘Alice in Wonderland’ and ‘Through the Looking-Glass and what Alice found there’, both of which are intriguing fantasies, almost making imagination real. From the latter, we have the memorable quote: ‘The question is’, said Alice, ‘whether you can make words mean different things.’ The question is, said Humpty Dumpty, ‘which is to be master, that’s all.’ It was rumoured that he had a not wholly healthy interest in young girls, although there is not a jot of evidence that he ever did anything untoward. From Alice’s fantasy world, the Scotsman Kenneth Graham takes us to the fantasy world of little animals, with ‘The Wind in the Willows’, written to his son. We see the daily lives of the toad, the badger, rat and mole in a typical English country setting. Beatrix Potter also wrote short books about animals, illustrating them herself. Of note are ‘The Tale of Peter Rabbit’ and the ‘Tale of Mrs.Tittlemouse.  She spent most of her later life in the Lake District, the most beautiful part of England. This had a kind effect on her writing.

Moving now to more social and even sexual themes, we come to D.H. (David Herbert Richard) Lawrence (1885-1930).
This man got through the bone to the marrow of passion, love and sex. His quintessential book is ‘Lady Chatterley’s Lover’, a story of illicit love, passion and unadulterated sex between the upper-class wife of an impotent aristocrat and the gamekeeper. Lawrence left England, and the book was published in Florence, not appearing in England until 1961, following a sensational obscenity trial. Lawrence wrote other books, such as ‘Women in Love’ and ‘Sons and Lovers’. He is very perceptive, revealing the real, rather than the politically correct and sanitised nonsense of hypocrisy. We can connect this to the English people’s dislike of being obvious, particularly when it comes to sex, and their embarrassment of sexual matters, often expressed in crude jokes.

Now back to the Irish: James Joyce (1882-1942)
was another of those linguists who chose Paris. His most well-known work is ‘Ulyses’, an example of his so-called ‘stream of consciousness’ writing, which tries to catch one’s deepest thoughts and imagination on paper, a kind of interior monologue. As such, it is naturally unstructured. ‘Ulyses’ deals with a day in Dublin, and a whole gaggle of characters.  ‘Finnegan’s Wake’ is another example, and has been linked to Giambattista Vico’s ‘New Science’, which contains a good deal about the origins of language. Joyce certainly pushes written language to its limits. In contrast, his ‘Dubliners’, a series of short stories about life in Dublin, is surprisingly prosaic in style. He influenced another Irishman, the playwright Samuel Becket (1906-1989),
another linguist residing in Paris, best known for ‘ En attendant Godot’, written originally in French. The gripping play ends without Godot arriving.

Let us now spare some thought for the wonderful and tragic Virginia Woolf,
known in particular for ‘To the Lighthouse’, ‘The Waves’, ‘Orlando’ and ‘Mrs. Dalloway’. As with Joyce, we see a certain amount of internal dialogue. Woolf was a leading light of the ‘Bloomsbury Group’, named after the area of London in which it met. She has also been seen as a feminist, having written : ‘A woman must have money  and a room of her own if she is to write fiction’. But does this not also apply to men? It is up to you to decide, by reading some of her work, whether or not she was a feminist. She is said to have had mental problems. At any rate, she drowned herself in the Thames.

Back now to the men. Aldous Huxley (1894-1963)
is best known for ‘Brave New World’ (1934), a particularly negative critique of the future, where Britain is a wasteland of human ‘robots’ and scientific breeding (he virtually predicted test-tube babies), with subordination the ideal of happiness. He developed the theme in 1959, with ‘Brave New World Revisited’. At any rate, he is relevant today, as is the inimitable literary giant George Orwell (1903-50),
whose real name was Eric Arthur Blair. His ‘1984’, published in 1948, predicts a future where the world is divided into huge power blocks, and where people are run on government propaganda. Wherever you live, ‘Big Brother’ watches you from a television screen, and so help you if you say anything against the government, or even try to have a loving relationship with someone. As for the Ministry of Truth, it is based on lying. ‘Animal Farm’ is an attack on communist totalitarianism. After Eton, Blair became a colonial policeman in Burma (he was born in Bengal), an experience which made him critical of the British Empire. ‘Burmese Days’ is a novel which brings out the hypocrisy of empire, and how social class mattered, in a story of unrequited love. Orwell was also a good short story writer. ‘Shooting an Elephant’ brings out the relationship between rulers and ruled, while ‘A Hanging’ is horrific in its detail. Orwell fought in the Spanish civil war, and wrote a very perceptive – if occasionally pedantic - book about the details of the conflict. He also spent several months living as a casual worker in London and Paris, working mainly as a dishwasher. He then produced a highly entertaining book, ‘Down and out in London and Paris’. Here is an example of his writing, from ‘England, your England’: ‘As I write, highly civilised human beings are flying overhead, trying to kill me. They do not feel any enmity against me as an individual, nor I against them. They are only “doing their duty”, as the saying goes. Most of them, I have no doubt, are kind-hearted law-abiding men who would never dream of committing murder in private life.’ Like several writers, Orwell was also a journalist. We cannot end without mentioning his essay ‘Politics and the English Language’, a highly entertaining but effective lambasting of the influence of political ideology on the English language, and very relevant today, with the erosion of clear English through computer language, sloppy education and political correctness.

From Orwell, we turn now to two children’s writers, although their books are also appropriate for adults. The South African J.R. Tolkien (1892-1973),
Professor of Anglo-Saxon at Oxford, is most well known for ‘Sir Gawain and the Green Knight’, ‘The Hobbit’ and ‘Lord of the Rings’, adventure stories laden with fantasy and drawing on Tolkien’s knowledge of the Celts. If I compare Tolkien to Rowling’s ‘Harry Potter’, the latter catapults itself out of existence. Roald Dahl (1916-1990)
is also a wonderful writer, primarily but not exclusively for children. Born in Wales of Norwegian parents, his daughter was once one of the girlfriends of a cousin of mine.  He wrote a series of short stories, ‘Tales of the Unexpected’, so gripping that they were serialised on television. Each story ends with a twist. Although they are for adults and older children, ‘Charlie and the Chocolate Factory’ is definitely for young people. ‘My Uncle Oswald’ is also an amusing book.

So we come to a mammoth of English literature, William Somerset Maugham (1874-1965).
Born in Paris, where his father was a legal adviser, hiss mother died when he was eight years of age, and his father two years later. He was sent to live with an uncle, the Vicar of Whitstable, apparently a cold character, and then attended King’s School, Canterbury, left early, and studied literature, philosophy and German at   Heidelberg, ending up studying medicine at St.Thomas’ Hospital in Lambeth, London, where he qualified as a doctor. His second book, ‘Lisa of Lambeth’ (1897), a story about working-class adultery, sold so well that Maugham became a full-time writer, moving to the south of France in 1928, around the time of his divorce (it is said that he had rather special relationships with various males). We cannot of course mention all his books (he even wrote some popular plays), but of note are: ‘Of Human Bondage’, autobiographical in nature, ‘Ashenden’, about a secret agent, and four volumes of very entertaining short stories, of which my favourite is ‘Salvatore’. Maugham was certainly a pretty rum character, and was good at irritating people, in particularly those whom he almost libeled in some of his books. For even if he did not mention real names, it was sometimes fairly obvious whom he meant. The following quote reveals some of Maugham’s sometimes bitter-sweet powers of describing people: ‘When she reddened, her pasty skin acquired a curiously mottled look, like strawberries and cream gone bad.’

Wending our way towards the writers of thrillers, I shall touch on only four, although there is a whole bevy of them. Graham Greene (1904-91),
who converted to Rome in 1926, was educated at Oxford, and worked for British Intelligence for a while. His thrillers are gripping, and delve deep into morality. One of his best thrillers, the ‘Human Factor’, is based on espionage, as is ‘Our Man In Havanna’. Other superb books are books are ‘The End of the Affair’, ‘The Honorary Consul’ and ‘Ministry of Fear’. John Le Carré (1931-  ),
whose real name is David Cornwell, is still going strong. After Oxford, he taught at Eton for two years, and then worked for MI5 (which handles, along with the Police’s Special Branch, internal security, but often has rows with MI6 about responsibility for Northern Ireland, because of the connexions with the Republic of Ireland). His espionage thriller ‘The Spy who came in from the Cold’, won him worldwide fame, and was made into a very good film. It brought out the reality of intelligence work, the drudgery and the mutual suspicions that abound in the incestuous world of institutionalised spying. Some of his other  books are ‘Smiley’s Circus’, ‘A Small town in Germany’, ‘A Perfect Spy’ and ‘The Constant Gardener’ which, despite the alleged  end of the Cold War, is as thrilling as ever, questioning the morality of big business. To get a sense of his style, here is the beginning of ‘A Small Town in Germany’: ‘Ten minutes to midnight: a pious Friday in May and a fine river mist lying in the market square. Bonn was a Balkan city, stained and secret […].’ In juxtaposition, Ian Fleming (1908-1964),
author of the extremely well-known Bond novels, emphasises, perhaps a mite too much, the more glamorous aspects of the job, but nevertheless remains plausible. He was in British Naval Intelligence for a while. Then we should mention Len Deighton (1929-  ),
who may have caught the writing bug when doing his National Service as a photographer attached to the Special Investigation Branch. ‘The Ipcress File’ made him an instant success, and was made into a good film, with Michael Caine as the hero. Some of his other books are ‘Horse under Water’, ‘Bomber’ and ‘Berlin Game’ (part of a series).

We cannot leave these chaps without mention of a lady writer, who, although not an espionage expert, is one of the best crime novelists: Agatha Christie (1890-1978),
wrote sixty six detective novels, using her experience as a hospital dispenser in the Great War to learn a good deal about poisons. Although her writing style is surprisingly simple, she manages to keep the reader hooked by misdirecting him. Who has not heard of Mrs. Marples and Hercule Poirot? ‘The Murder of Roger Ackroyd’, ‘Murder on the Orient Express’, ‘Ten Little Niggers’ and ‘The Mousetrap’ are just a few of her works. P.D.James was also an extremely good crime writer.

Before now moving to a small selection of British poets and their poetry, we shall look at Henry Williamson,
since he connects well to our first poet, Ted Hughes (see below for a picture... he's quite striking), who knew him, and spoke at his funeral. Williamson was a writer, journalist and farmer, who was in love with nature. He fought in the Great War, becoming disgusted with the greed and bigotry that had caused it, and determined that Britain and Germany should never go to war again. Because he had supported Oswald Mosley and his Fascists, and had admired Hitler before the next world war, a few small-minded individuals tried to damage his reputation. It is silly that the ‘Norton Anthology of English Literature’ does not include him, while including many lesser writers. After all, Oscar Wilde believed that art is for art’s sake, and should not be polluted by politics. Writers should be able to express their views without being sent to Coventry. The greatness of his books, however, saw him through. His masterpiece is ‘Tarka the Otter’, essentially about an otter being hunted to death. The reader actually becomes an otter. Williamson spent many months studying and watching otters before and while he wrote the book. So good was it, that Walt Disney twice approached him for the film rights, and was roundly rejected. It was eventually made into a proper film, and Williamson died on the same day that the filming of a dying Tarka was taking place. Uncanny or merely coincidental?  ‘Salar the Salmon’ is another masterpiece, as is his series of books on the life of Willie Maddison. The ‘Beautiful Years’ and ‘Dandelion Days’, partly autobiographical, describe beautifully a boy growing into adolescence and adulthood.

And so to our poetic interlude: Laurie Lee
was the quintessential Englishman:

‘Far-fetched with tales of other worlds and ways,
My skin well-oiled with wines of the Levant,
I set my face into a filial smile
To greet the pale, domestic kiss of Kent.
[…]
The hedges choke with roses fat as cream.’ (from ‘Home from Abroad’).

John Betjeman (a poet laureate)
 and lover of old England, loved Victoriana, the smell of old churches and musty books. But he is also perceptive about people: the following are extracts about an English lady at a service in Westminster Abbey, during the world war:

‘Gracious Lord, oh bomb the Germans.
Spare their women for Thy Sake,
And if that is not too easy
We will pardon Thy mistake.
But gracious Lord, what’er shall be,
Don’t let anyone bomb me.

Keep our Empire undismembered
Guide our forces by Thy hand,
Gallant blacks from far Jamaica,
Honduras and Togoland;
Protect them Lord in all their fights,
And, even more, protect the whites.

[…]

Now I feel a little better,
What a treat to hear thy word,
Where the bones of leading statesmen,
Have so often been interr’d.
And now, dear Lord, I cannot wait
Because I have a luncheon date.’ (from ‘In Westminster Abbey’).

Unlike Betjeman, Charles Causley
tends to look more at individual people and events, and is not as nostalgic. As regards his views on poetry, he writes in his introduction to a selection of his poems: ‘What a poem “means” is something that the writer as well as the reader each must decide alone. Only one thing is certain: that, unlike arithmetic, the correct answers may all be right, yet all be different.’ His imagery grips you hard:

‘Bank holiday, a sky of guns, the river
Slopping black silver on the level stair.
A war-memorial that aims for ever
Its stopped, stone barrel on the enormous air.’ (from ‘At Grantchester’)

or

‘Oh mother my mouth is full of stars
As cartridges in the tray
My blood is a twin-branched scarlet tree
And it runs all runs away.’ (From ‘Song of the Dying Gunner A.A.1’).

or

‘Charlotte she was gentle
But they found her in the flood
Her Sunday beads among the reeds
Beaming with her blood.’ (from ‘The Ballad of Charlotte Dymond’).

From poor Charlotte Dymond, we move to Clifford Dyment:

DYMENT'S ‘Fox’, begins like this:

‘Exploiter of the shadows
He moved among the fences,
A strip of action coiling
Around his farmyard fancies.’

And so we come to another mammoth, a poet laureate into the bargain, Ted Hugheswho (see above) admired Henry Williamson. Cambridge-educated Yorkshireman Hughes was fascinated by the natural violence of nature - in particular as regards the behaviour of animals - , in power and in death:

‘I sit in the top of the wood, my eyes closed.
Inaction, no falsifying dream
Between my hooked head and hooked feet:
Or in a sleep rehearse perfect kills and eat.’ (from ‘Hawk Roosting’).

or

‘Terrifying are the attent sleek thrushes on the lawn,
More coiled steel than living – a poised
Dark deadly eye, those delicate legs
Triggered to stirrings beyond sense – with a start,
                                                              a bounce, a stab
Overtake the instant and drag out some writhing thing.
 No indolent procrastinations and no yawning stares,
No sighs or head-scrathings. Nothing but bounce
                                                                          and stab
And a ravening second.’ (from ‘Thrushes’).

or

‘The pig lay on a barrow dead.
It weighed, they said, as much as three men.
Its eyes closed, pink white eyelashes.
Its trotters stuck straight out.’ (‘View of a Pig’).

Hughes, who superbly described November as ‘the month of the drowned dog’, had a somewhat intense yet sad relationship with his wife, the American poetess, Silvia Plath, who committed suicide, allegedly because of Hughes relationship(s?) with another woman or more. Pity about the children: and Sylvia’s son committed suicide forty six years after his mother did. Nature, power and death.

Our last two poems are by me, and I feel constrained to tell you that if a poem is to be unadulterated, and above the shackles of convention and/or self-interest, whether good or bad, it must come directly from the heart. The only question is how pure is your heart.

 ‘WILD RIVER TROUT


Dark shadow lies beneath, no movement;
Not even a twitch of the delicate tail
While it seeks its food.
More than hidden, it is part of the river.
It darts, too quick for eye to follow,
You see it in its new position.
The upward stab, the plucking bite,
The munching seconds, invisible to you.
You see only spreading ripples,
Then the golden glint, the creamy belly,
In the evening sun.
You cast, the sudden tug shocks you,
Despite your expectation.
It pulls and judders at your soul;
Such beauty, as you take him out,
Designed for hunting fly,
To feed its perfect muscles.
Body sculpted to living perfection;
Colours glisten, yet as deep as the river.
The hazel eye stares you out
Long after the death.
It hunts your soul.
Thank God for procreation.’

or

REMEMBER


To your beauty-hunting body,
Oh grant some time to feeling.

To your love-thirsting heart,
Oh grant some time to harmony.

To your self-seeking soul,
Please accord some time to thought.

To your success-hungry ego,
Just grant some time to others.

To your power-seeking eyes,
Oh grant some time to introspection.

To your adventure-seeking feet,
Oh grant some time to knowledge.

To your God-seeking soul,
Please give some time to prayer.

Let us now talk quickly about John Fowles
, who loved Greece. Indeed, one of his most famous novels, ‘The Magus’, is set on the island of Spetse, a story of intrigue, passion, obsession and sex, with an orchestrator, ‘Conchis’. ‘The Collector’ is also a rather frightening little story of a girl trapped by an obsessive collector, ending nastily.

Returning to America, John Steinbeck
is of considerable note for his novels about life during the Great Depression, in particular ‘Of Mice and Men’ and ‘The Grapes of Wrath’.

Let us finish, as we began, with a couple of playwrights. Harold Pinter
famous for his skilful repartee, wrote, inter alia, ‘The Birthday Party’ and ‘The Caretaker’. He was awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature in 2005, and, although part-Jewish, led a group of Jews who campaigned for justice for the Palestinians, embarrassing fanatic Israeli Zionists. To obtain a flavour of his political views, you can look at his ‘A New world Order’, published in 1991. He was awarded an honorary professorship by the University of Thessaloniki.

Another well-known playwright is Tom Stoppard,
also a master of repartee, who escaped from Czechoslovakia in 1938, at the age of one. He wrote, inter alia, ‘Arcadia’. He also wrote and spoke on political matters.

Now we really must stop, and move on to a few typical examination questions:

‘Compare George Bernard Shaw’s and Oscar Wilde’s works.’

‘Do you think that Maugham was more imaginative in his writing than Orwell?’

‘It is said that Ted Hughes was obsessed with nature, power and death. What do you think?’

‘Compare the works of Agatha Christie to those of John Le Carré.’

 Have fun!

YEAR III AND IV - COMIC SKETCH SET IN CROMWELL'S TIMES

domenica 16 aprile 2017

YEAR IV AND V EMILY BRONTE and Wuthering Heights

Emily Brontë - Biography


"Wuthering Heights is a strange sort of book — baffling all regular criticism; yet, it is impossible to begin and not finish it; and quite as impossible to lay it aside afterwards and say nothing about it." This review, from Douglas Jerrold's Weekly Newspaper, was one of the first receptions to Emily Brontë's novel, and concluded with the line, "we must leave it to our readers to decide what sort of a book it is." The conclusion in this review, which is the extent of praise the novel received on its publication, pertains not only to the novel Wuthering Heights but to Emily Brontë herself; it is up to readers to determine what type of writer Brontë was: Besides Wuthering Heights, only a few poems of hers exist and precious little of her personal history exists to complement those writings. Thus, in order to ascertain what type of writer Brontë was, critics must speculate based on a limited family history, some poems, and one excellent novel.

Brontë was one of six children born to Reverend Patrick Brontë and Maria Branwell Brontë. Born in Thornton, Yorkshire, England, on July 30, 1818, she was the sister of Maria, Elizabeth, Charlotte, Anne, and Branwell. Her family moved to Haworth when she was two years old, and here she first experienced the moors, a part of the Pennine Chain of mountains, andhere she lived until she died 30 years later.

A variety of conflicting influences shaped her life. Her father, of Irish descent, was known for his poetry and imagination even though he was the cleric. Her mother, a staunch Methodist, died when Emily was only three years old, so what she knew of her she learned from her siblings and her Aunt Elizabeth (Maria's sister), who raised the children after Maria's death. Elizabeth brought a religious fervor to the house that Brontë soon rejected.

Brontë's environment shaped her life and her work. The village of Haworth was isolated and surrounded by moors; thus, the one world she knew and lived in became the setting for her only novel. Paralleling her own life, she creates motherless characters in Wuthering Heights.

Writing was a means of amusement for the Brontë children. After the two oldest sisters died, the remaining siblings began writing plays and poems, creating a world called Angria and Gondal. These worlds became little books and the sources for later poetry and prose. Emily Brontë went to school, but she was unable to stay there. Possessing a reclusive nature, she had longings and desires for her home on the moors, which prompted her return home after a scant three months.

In the following year, 1837, she attempted to teach school. This endeavor lasted eight months, but she could not handle the stress and again returned home. In 1842 she went with Charlotte to Brussels to study foreign languages and school management in order to open a school in Haworth. Brontë had success there. One of her professors stated that she "had a head for logic and a capability for argument, unusual in a man, and rare indeed in a woman," but she returned to Haworth when her aunt died in 1843. Living with her father at the parsonage in Haworth, this became a period of creativity. Although the earliest dated poem is from 1836, the majority of her poetry that survives was written during this time.

Like most authors, Emily Brontë was a product of her environment, and this directly influenced her writing. During her life she had no close friends, was interested in mysticism, and enjoyed her solitude outdoors. All of these elements grace both her poems and Wuthering Heights. In fact, many contemporary critics praise Emily Brontë first and foremost as a poet, marveling at the poetic nature of Wuthering Heights.

In 1845 Charlotte found some of the poetry that Emily had been writing and eventually persuaded her sister to attempt to publish her work. Charlotte and Emily, along with their sister Anne, eventually published a collection of poems under the male names of Currer, Ellis, and Acton Bell. Each pseudonym begins with the same consonant as the writer's name. The sisters paid to have the collection published, and even though it only sold two copies, they were undaunted and continued to write. This time each sister wrote a novel.

Evidence suggests that Emily Brontë began writing Wuthering Heights in December 1845 and completed it the next year. A year after that, in July of 1847, Wuthering Heights was accepted for publication; however, it was not printed until December, following the success of Jane Eyre.

Although Wuthering Heights did not meet with the critical success Jane Eyre received, contemporary critics tend to consider Emily the best writer of the Brontë sisters. Emily Brontë's highly imaginative novel of passion and hate was too savage and animal-like and clumsy in its own day and time, but contemporary audiences consider it mild.

The fall following publication, Emily Brontë left home to attend her brother's funeral. She caught a severe cold that spread to her lungs, and she died of tuberculosis on December 19, 1848.

Following the publication of poems, Jane Eyre, Wuthering Heights, and Anne's novel Agnes Grey, audiences considered all three "Bells" to be one author. Confusion continued as Anne published The Tenant of Wildfell Hall. Wuthering Heights was reissued with poems and a biographical notice by Charlotte. By this time, both Emily and Anne had died, and Charlotte succinctly stated how and why she and her sisters assumed the name of Bell. Charlotte Brontë also provided insight into the life of her sister.

Long after its initial publication and subsequent death of its author, Wuthering Heights has become one of the classics of English literature. After the reissue of Emily Brontë's text, the editors of the Examiner commented upon Charlotte's introduction. Their words and sentiments are often echoed by admirers of Wuthering Heights: "We have only most unfeignedly to deplore the blight which fell prematurely on sure rich intellectual promise, and to regret that natures so rare and noble should so early have passed away."

YEAR IV AND V - GOTHIC LITERATURE (PART OF VICTORIAN LITERATURE)

                                                            GOTHIC LITERATURE

A genre that has been rediscovered over the past 40 years or so
It is indicative of the deep transformations of the cultural discourse of late 18th century
“Gothic fiction” then evolves into a genre and its many spin offs, transformations etc
“gothic” as a connotation (an “umbrella-term” today) is different from the bulk of fiction that was produced in the late decades of the century

THE GOTHIC/”GOTHIC”/
GOTHICISM
By extension, it came to designate the macabre, mysterious, fantastic, supernatural,
and, again, the terrifying, especially the pleasurably terrifying in literature more generally.
Gothic in Victorian literature (for example, in the novels of Dickens and the Brontës),
Gothic in American fiction (from Poe and Hawthorne through Faulkner)
Gothic in films, television, and videos in postmodern culture.

The Gothic novel
Some elements in common with the
”Age/Literature of Sensibility’ (1750-1798):The vogue for the picturesque
Emphasis on fantasy, imagination, sensibility and the appraisal of emotion
The cult of the sublime and beautiful



*The importance of natural landscape as a setting for the extraordinary adventures of the plot
The abyss, the chasm, vertical paradigms of space






Gothicism and Orientalism
The    European    Romantic    imagination    was    saturated    with   
Orientalism,    but    it    reflected    persistent    ambivalence   
concerning    the    East,    complicated    in    Britain    by    colonial   
anxiety    and    imperial    guilt.
Pleasurable    terror    and    pleasurable    exoticism    operating    in   
a    kindred    way


Characteristics of the Gothic novel
The young maid’s virtue is constantly under threat or persecuted
Young women are generally coveted and predated by evil men who want to possess/marry/murder them
Spirits, ghosts, revenants, mysterious presences

The ending is almost invariably positive
But the dominant mood and emotion is that of strong emotion,
the SUBLIME, TERROR and ASTONISHMENT




THE GOTHIC  novel’s main characteristics are clearly at odds with
Augustan/NEOCLASSICAL PRINCIPLES AND IDEALS
And oriented to a fascination with an obsession with death, the uncanny, and
incontrollable passions
The  fictional world of the gothic novel gives form to amorphous fears and
impulses common to all mankind, recurring to a combination of different
elements (from the unconscious to fairy tale, myth, folklore, and romance)

Early Gothic novels differentiate starkly between good and evil
THE GOTHIC NOVEL DISCOVERS ”THE PLEASURES OF EVIL‘
(hence, to oversimply a complex issue, its longevity as a  genre)

The Gothic novel AND THE SUBLIME
The Gothic novel’s opposition to the neoclassical ideals is largely indebted to
the rediscovery of the Sublime, theorized by the philosopher Edmund Burke in
his higly influential
A Philosophical Enquiry into the Orisgin of Our Ideas of the Sublime and
Beautiful (1757)


The sublime and the beautiful represent the primary categories of aesthetic experience
The beautiful is essentially a social category lodged primarily in form
( what is small, delicate, smooth)
The sublime is a representation of experience capable of instilling fear by
bringing someone to the perception of fear for his own self-preservation

The Gothic novel AND THE SUBLIME
Burke’s Treatise:
Whatever is fitted in any sort to excite the ideas of pain, and danger, that is to say, whatever is in any sort terrible, or is conversant about terrible objects, or operates in a manner analogous to terror, is a source of the sublime; that is it is productive of the strongest emotion which the mind is capable of feeling…
But as pain is stronger in its operation than pleasure, so
death is in general a much more affecting idea than pain;
because there are very few pains, however exquisite,  which are
not preferred to death; nay, what generally  makes pain itself, if I
may say so, more painful, is that it is considered as an emissary
of this king of terrors. When danger or pain press too nearly, they
are incapable of giving any delight, and are simply terrible; but at
certain distances, and with certain modifications, they may be,
and they are delightful, as we every day experience (Burke)


Ann Radcliffe
The Italian
 (1797), pp.
62-63
Ellena accepted the cool refreshment offered her, the first she had
taken on the road. Her companions having emptied their glasses drew
up the blind, and, notwithstanding the almost intolerable heat of noon,
the carriage proceeded. Fainting under its oppression, Ellena
entreated that the windows might be open, when the men, in
compliance with their own necessity rather than with her requests,
lowered the blinds, and she had a glimpse of the lofty region of the
mountains, but of no object that could direct her conjecture
concerning where she was. She saw only pinnacles and vast precipices
of various-tinted marbles, intermingled with scanty vegetation, such as
stunted pinasters, dwarf oak and holly, which gave dark touches to the
many-coloured cliffs , and sometimes stretched in shadowy masses to
the deep vallies, that, winding into obscurity, seemed to invite curiosity
to explore the scenes beyond. 


The Italian: an example of the sublime
Below these bold precipices extended the gloomy region of olive-trees,
and lower still other rocky steeps sunk towards the plains, bearing
terraces crowned with vines, and where often the artificial soil was
propped by thickets of juniper, pomegranate and oleander.
Ellena, after having been so long shut in darkness, and brooding over her own
alarming circumstances, found temporary, though feeble, relief in once
more looking upon the face of nature; till, her spirits being gradually
revived and elevated by the grandeur of the images around her, she
said to herself, 'If I am condemned to misery, surely I could endure it
with more fortitude in scenes like these, than amidst the tamer
landscapes of nature! Here, the objects seem to impart somewhat of
their own force, their own sublimity, to the soul. It is scarcely possible
to yield to the pressure of misfortune while we walk, as with the Deity,
amidst his most stupendous works.



The Gothic novel
GOTHIC FICTION IS PRIMARILY CONVENTIONAL:
 IT SOON BEGINS TO RE-USE AND TRANSFORM ITS OWN MATERIAL
IN AN INTERTEXTUAL WAY
AUTHORS MADE USE AND MODIFIED EACH OTHER’S DEVICES
IT CAN BE CONSIDERED AS PART OF SENTIMENTAL FICTION
A COMMON TRAIT LIES IN A PECULIAR FORM OF SYMBOLISM  FOUND IN GOTHIC TALES
Not allegory, because the referents are deliberately undeterminate
Gothic fiction is also indebted to Shakespeare, Spenser, the Graveyard poets, antiquarianism and sentimentalism

Horace Walpole

The foundational text of the Gothic novel is: Horace Walpole’s
The Castle of Otranto
(1764):
A new genre is created out of the combination of many different
components
Subgenres followed and flourished:
Sentimental
Historical
Orientalist,
Horrific
The tradition continues well into the 20th c with its continual
transformations and adaptations

Among the highlights of Gothic fiction
The Gothic novel

  - William Beckford,  Vatheck (1782-6)

Matthew Gregory Lewis,  The Monk (1796) perhaps the masterpiece of the genre


Mary Shelley, Frankenstein (1818)


Gothicism and Orientalism are often interacting
sensationalism and exoticism are kindred
experiences: unreality, otherness


The Gothic novel
Most notably: with reference to the ”female Gothic’ (authored bywomen writers - Ann Radcliffe, M.Shelley - and depicting women in the Gothic)
There are 4 important aspects:
The gendered construction of the Female Gothic heroine and hero
THE LINK BETWEEN THE GOTHIC ”PLACE’ AND FEMALE SEXUALITY
The conflation of money and class issues with issues of femininity


The Gothic space
 the construction of space in the Gothic novel is largely sexualized and gendered especially in relation to female sexuality and fears of sexuality
The traditional setting of a castle or a (Catholic) abbey which can be a plece of safety against external assaults but has as its foundations a complicated maze of underground vaults and dark
passages and in its bedrooms sliding panels and trapdoors - It is the setting of sexual fantasies of penetration and violation and it is figured then in terms of ‘inner space‘

The Gothic building, traditionally a castle has a signifying function
 in identifying a woman’s body when she is experiencing the conflict
over sexual arousal - In this critical  interpretation place is suggestive of the fact thet the
heroine’s most sinister enemy is in fact her awakening sexuality


The Gothic sublime
The passion caused by  the great and sublime is Astonishment
Terror is the ruling principle of the sublime
Ann Radcliffe: On the Supernatural in Poetry, 1802
Distinguishes between
TERROR  and HORROR
Respectively: positive and negative effect of an emotion
Only terror can be a source of the sublime


ABOUT THE CASTLE OF OTRANTO by Horace Walpole
The Castle of Otranto is a 1764 novel by Horace Walpole. It is generally regarded as the first gothic novel, initiating a literary genre which would become extremely popular in the later 18th and early 19th century, with authors such as Charles Maturin, Ann Radcliffe, Bram Stoker, Edgar Allan Poe and Daphne du Maurier.

Plot

The Castle of Otranto tells the story of Manfred, lord of the castle, and his family. The book begins on the wedding-day of his sickly son Conrad and princess Isabella. Shortly before the wedding, however, Conrad is crushed to death by a gigantic helmet that falls on him from above. This inexplicable event is particularly ominous in light of an ancient prophecy, "that the castle and lordship of Otranto should pass from the present family, whenever the real owner should be grown too large to inhabit it". Manfred, terrified that Conrad's death signals the beginning of the end for his line, resolves to avert destruction by marrying Isabella himself while divorcing his current wife Hippolita, who he feels has failed to bear him a proper heir.
However, as Manfred attempts to marry Isabella, she escapes to a church with the aid of a peasant named Theodore. Manfred orders Theodore's death while talking to the friar Jerome, who ensured Isabella's safety in the church. When Theodore removes his shirt to be killed, Jerome recognizes a marking below his shoulder and identifies Theodore as his own son. Jerome begs for his son's life, but Manfred says Jerome must either give up the princess or his son's life. They are interrupted by a trumpet and the entrance of knights from another kingdom who want to deliver Isabella. This leads the knights and Manfred to race to find Isabella.
Theodore, having been locked in a tower by Manfred, is freed by Manfred's daughter Matilda. He races to the underground church and finds Isabella. He hides her in a cave and blocks it to protect her from Manfred and ends up fighting one of the mysterious knights. Theodore badly wounds the knight, who turns out to be Isabella's father, Frederic. With that, they all go up to the castle to work things out. Frederic falls in love with Matilda and he and Manfred begin to make a deal about marrying each other's daughters. Manfred, suspecting that Isabella is meeting Theodore in a tryst in the church, takes a knife into the church, where Matilda is meeting Theodore. Thinking his own daughter is Isabella, he stabs her. Theodore is then revealed to be the true prince of Otranto and Matilda dies, leaving Manfred to repent. Theodore becomes king and eventually marries Isabella because she is the only one who can understand his true sorrow.


The Castle of Otranto
Many  features which become established conventions  of the genre
already appear in the seminal novel The Castle of Otranto (1764)
a medieval tale with a medieval setting, villain hero, ghosts and
wonders - derived from medieval romance: Walpole innovates
the novel by turning to antiquity (see the Ossian poems, 1795)
Walpole’s preface: an attempt to blend the two kinds of romance, the
old and the new

An indirect narration: the first Gothic characteristic in its
presentation is the ancient manuscript rediscovered: it imparts an
indirect air of strangeness
The novel is constantly on the verge of bathos*: theatricality and
amusement! *a sudden change from sthing that is beautiful,
moral or serious , to sthing that is ordinary, silly or unimportant

Thus, in the first of the Gothic novels, the problem of evil is
already presented as a psychological problem created in the
ambience of the family ( Manfred’s obsession with offspring to
ensure possession of the castle)
Characters are simplified figures

Correspondences between physical appearance and spiritual state
A sort of symbolic nightmare
The  central device is the most famous of all Gothic devices:
THE IDENTITY OF THE CASTLE OR HOUSE WITH ITS OWNER
AND A MANIFESTATIONOF HIS MIND
AS A SITE OF CONFINEMENT /ENTRAPMENT FOR OTHER
CHARACTERS WHO ARE DOMINATED AND CHASED BY HIM


The Castle of Otranto

THE GREAT DEAL OF SEXUAL SYMBOLISM ALSO
ADDS TO THE EXPLORATION OF THE VILLAIN’S
PERSONALITY

The central theme is the psychological aberration of incest (a
staple item in Gothic Ficton) and the editor draws attention to that

The responsibility of fathers whose bad deeds affect the lives of
their children